Ticker

6/recent/ticker-posts

Tinubu: Garbled Speeches, Public Falls, and the Constitutional Question About Capacity

By Uduma Kalu

"Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel."  — Samuel Johnson, 7 April 1775

What did Johnson mean? He did not mean that every person who loves their country is a scoundrel. He meant that when a public figure has no argument left, he may reach for the flag instead of an answer. He may say, I am doing this for the country. He may say, those who question me question the country. In Johnson's sense, patriotism can be used as a refuge — a place to hide from scrutiny, rather than a reason to accept it.

That idea is worth keeping in mind when we ask a question that is not about character, but about capacity. Why does any leader seek to remain in office when public scrutiny of his capacity is growing? Is it patriotism? Is it habit? Is it pressure from supporters? Is it something else? The public cannot know a leader's motive. What the public can know is the public record — what was said, what was done, and what the Constitution says should happen when capacity is in doubt.

We do not have President Bola Tinubu's medical records. The Presidency has not published them. No medical panel has been constituted under Section 144 of the Constitution to examine him. What we do have is what every Nigerian has: his public appearances on video. His public stumbles. His speeches, on live television, in his own words, including passages where he appeared to lose the thread of his sentence. His unsteady steps, on stairs, on podiums, on red carpets, where aides were seen holding his arm. What appears, on video, to be an unsteady hand when he holds a microphone or a rail.

We are not doctors. We cannot diagnose him from a video. No journalist can. Only a medical panel, after examination, can say whether he is suffering from an infirmity of body or mind within the meaning of Section 144. But the public record raises a constitutional question that will not go away. Can a President who, in public, has appeared to struggle to finish a sentence, to keep the names in a story straight, and to walk without assistance, discharge the functions of his office under Section 130(2) — Head of State, Chief Executive, Commander-in-Chief? That is not a diagnosis. That is a question the Constitution itself invites.

The Constitution does not ask a President to be young. It asks him to do one thing: discharge the functions of his office. Section 130(2) says the President shall be the Head of State, the Chief Executive of the Federation and Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces. Section 137(1)(c) says a person shall not be qualified for election if he is adjudged to be a lunatic or otherwise declared to be of unsound mind. Section 144 says a President shall cease to hold office if, by a resolution of two-thirds of the executive council, it is declared that he is incapable of discharging the functions of his office, and the declaration is verified by a medical panel, and the panel certifies that he is suffering from such infirmity of body or mind as renders him permanently incapable of discharging the functions of his office. Section 145 says if he declares himself unable, the Vice-President shall act. Section 146 says if the office becomes vacant, the Vice-President shall hold it. That is the law.

In Owerri, on 17 November 2022, in a town hall with businessmen, he tried to say this is a real town hall, not hullabaloo. What he said, on TVC live feed, was, "Here is a successful, again, a town hall different from balabloo bloo blu bulaba." He did not correct it on the broadcast. In Kaduna, asked about climate change, he said, "It is a question of how do you prevent a church rat from eating a poisoned holy communion?" No policy followed on that broadcast. In Kano, he said government should recruit 50 million soldiers, and give them agbada in the morning, cassava in the afternoon. Agbada is a robe. Agbado is corn. His supporters later said he meant 50,000, not 50 million. In Jos, he said, "God bless PD...APC." He then corrected himself to APC. He called Simon Lalong, his campaign DG, Solomon Dalong. He told voters to collect their APV. He meant PVC. He called Atiku Abubakar, former Vice President, Senate President. Atiku was never Senate President. He promised Omo-Agege would be governor of the Niger Delta State. There is no Niger Delta State.

As President, similar moments continued on the public record. In the Villa, on 19 October 2026, defending subsidy removal, he said, "When Moses and Musa left Egypt." Musa is the Arabic name for Moses. Critics said he spoke as if they were two different men. Supporters said he was referring to the same figure in two traditions. In Akwa Ibom, in November 2026, he said, "Once upon a time there was Moses and Pharaoh. He was in Egypt where he was a magician, he did everything. He won't let the believer go... I give Moses and these people opening to pass. Those who were chasing them, as across there, they were perishable in the ocean." Critics said he had mixed the characters, used "perishable" where "perished" would be expected, and said "I give" where the Biblical account says God parted the sea. Supporters said he was speaking extemporaneously and his meaning — that Nigeria should move forward and not return to subsidy — was clear. He then said, "We go forward and it's going forward," and repeated the phrase. In December 2024, he called the 10th National Assembly the 11th. In March 2026, he spoke of "high voltage heat" and "the Biobaku party." There is no party of that name. In October 2026, after three and a half years as President, he said it would bring "Governor Bola Tinubu back for a second time." He had been Governor from 1999 to 2007.

The public falls are also on video. Eagle Square, Democracy Day: he slipped, he stumbled, guards caught him. Kaduna, Arewa House: he misstepped, caught himself on the table. Airport stairs at night: an aide walked backwards, watching his feet. Turkey, guard of honour: he stumbled on a blue carpet. The Presidency confirmed he missed his step very briefly. Kaduna, 24 October 2026: video shows the First Lady putting what appears to be a small substance into his mouth before he speaks. The Presidency has not explained it. The video alone does not establish what it was.

Tinubu is not the first Nigerian President whose health became a matter of public debate. Buhari was elected in 2015, already 72. He spent 154 days on medical leave in London. In 2017 alone, 104 days. He transmitted a letter under Section 145, and the Vice-President acted in his absence. Critics said a small group around him exercised influence while he was away. His supporters said the constitutional process was followed. His border closure in 2019 coincided with rice prices rising. His naira redesign in 2022 coincided with cash shortages, long ATM queues, and a Supreme Court ruling against the policy. He kept subsidy for eight years, spending N11 trillion, then removed it, reinstated it, and removed it again. He kept Service Chiefs for five years beyond retirement, while bandits attacked the Nigerian Defence Academy itself. Debt rose from N12 trillion to N77 trillion. Before Buhari, Yar'Adua disappeared for 78 days in Jeddah in 2009. His aides restricted access to him, and his signature appeared on a budget document while he was abroad. He died on 5 May 2010. The Senate later invoked the Doctrine of Necessity to make Jonathan Acting President.

After Buhari, the debate widened to Paul Biya. President of Cameroon since 1982, 43 years. Ninety-two years old in 2026. Re-elected in October 2025 at 92. In 2024, he disappeared from public view for 42 days. His government said he was on a private stay in Europe and warned against speculation about his health. When he reappeared, he walked slowly, aides holding his arm, he read speeches slowly, with long pauses, he appeared to fall asleep in meetings. At his own inauguration, he had to be helped to stand, helped to sit, helped to walk. Critics in Cameroon and abroad said he was too frail to govern and that those around him exercised power in his name. His supporters said he remained the choice of voters and that his government continued to function. The victim, critics said, was not Biya, but the nation.

Back to Tinubu, critics link his public difficulties to his policies. They point to subsidy removal on 29 May 2023: "Subsidy is gone." No transition. No palliatives. No transport plan announced on that day. Petrol rose from N197 to N617 overnight, then to N1,500 in 2025. Naira float in June 2023: floated without reserves announced in advance. Naira fell from N460 to one dollar to N1,600 in 2024, to N1,900 in 2025. Tax reforms in 2024: four bills that drew objections on VAT and derivation, and had to be withdrawn and re-drafted. Student loan in 2023: only 500,000 accessed it out of 2.1 million, according to official figures cited in press reports. CNG buses: promised 5,500, delivered 2,000 by 2026, many without stations to fill them, according to press reports. Food: "We will not import food," then approved 250,000 tonnes duty-free, then banned it again. Supporters of the President say these policies were necessary reforms, that short-term pain was expected, and that implementation delays are common in a large federation. Critics say the policies were announced without adequate preparation, and that the country has paid the price. Debt, according to the Debt Management Office, rose from N77 trillion in 2023 to N166.79 trillion by June 2026.

The Lagos-Calabar Coastal Highway is the example critics cite most often of a policy that changed direction mid-course while its cost remained disputed. It was presented as a 750-kilometre coastal highway from Victoria Island, Lagos, to Calabar, through Ogun, Ondo, Delta, Bayelsa, Rivers and Akwa Ibom. Construction began in March 2024. Section One, 47.47 kilometres from Victoria Island to Lekki, was approved at N1.067 trillion. In April 2024, Minister of Works David Umahi put the cost at N4 billion per kilometre. By October 2026, he put it at about N7.5 billion per kilometre for a standard two-lane equivalent, and said the figure covered concrete pavement, shoreline protection, retaining walls, solar lighting, flyovers, underpasses and sand filling. Critics said that was a near-doubling. The Minister said the two figures were not comparable, because the later figure reflected a six-lane configuration and additional works. On 12 October 2026, Umahi announced that Sections 4A and 4B, originally expected to run along the coastline of Ogun and Ondo States, would be redirected inland through Edo State to connect with the existing East-West Road. He attributed the decision to deep pits, peat soils, swampy terrain and flood risk, and said construction pits in Ondo ran deeper than 100 metres. He quoted President Tinubu as directing that the highway should pass through the existing East-West Road rather than opening new alignments. Critics called it a somersault. Human rights lawyer Femi Falana, SAN, said the coastal road had now become a land road, and asked what the N15 trillion earmarked for the project would be spent on. Niger Delta groups petitioned for restoration of the original coastal route, saying the diversion would bypass the riverine communities the road was meant to serve. The Government's response has itself shifted. At one point, Umahi said the East-West Road work was the diversion. Later, he said the East-West Road work — about 400 kilometres from Edo to Cross River — was a separate, complementary project, not an abandonment of the coastal highway. He also said there was no single design for the whole 750 kilometres, that the project was being designed and costed section by section, and that the widely cited N15 trillion total was not an official total. Supporters say engineering flexibility is legitimate and that difficult terrain required a detour. Critics say a project of this size should have had feasibility studies, soil investigations, environmental assessments and a fixed design before construction began, and that changing the alignment after construction began, while the cost figure rises, raises questions about planning, value for money, and accountability. The demolitions add to that question. Landmark Leisure Beach in Lagos was partially demolished for the highway. Its owner said he had not been adequately compensated. The Minister said the owner should produce a certificate of occupancy. No court has finally determined that dispute in the reporting reviewed.

On security, the record is contested but the numbers are grave. On taking office, Tinubu said security would be the top priority of his administration. Critics say that promise has not been kept. Amnesty International, marking his second anniversary in office in May 2025, said over 10,217 Nigerians had been killed since he took office, that new armed groups had emerged, including Lakurawa in Sokoto and Kebbi, and that 638 villages in Zamfara had been sacked. A Premium Times investigation, using ACLED data, documented 7,472 deaths and 12,584 abductions during his first two years. The 2026 Global Terrorism Index ranked Nigeria fourth among countries most affected by terrorism in 2025, up from sixth in 2024, recording 171 terrorist attacks in 2025 compared with 120 in 2024, and 750 terrorism-related deaths, a 46 percent increase, with civilians accounting for 67 percent of fatalities. The Government says military operations have degraded groups in some areas, that it has replaced Service Chiefs, appointed a new Defence Minister, and announced emergency measures, and that the figures cited by critics do not capture operations that prevented attacks. Critics say the figures show that, whatever the operations, killings, kidnappings and mass abductions have continued on a scale that amounts to failure to protect life and property, which is the first duty of a Commander-in-Chief under Section 130(2).

That failure, critics say, is made worse by absence at the scene. In Benue, after the Yelewata attack of 14-15 June 2025, in which the Government put the death toll at 59 while civil society groups put it at around 200, Tinubu visited Makurdi on 18 June 2025. He visited survivors in hospital in Makurdi, met officials, and asked security chiefs why no arrest had been made. He did not go to Yelewata itself. His own explanation, given in Makurdi, was: "I aborted my visit to Yelwata because of the rain and bad roads." Critics, including Peter Obi and Adewole Adebayo, said a Commander-in-Chief with a presidential air fleet could not claim that a part of his own country was unreachable, and that survivors needed presence, not explanation. In Plateau, after the March 2026 attack in Angwan Rukuba, Jos North, in which at least 20 people were reported killed, Tinubu met affected families at Jos Airport on 2 April 2026. He did not go to the affected communities. His spokesperson said the visit was affected by a scheduled meeting with the President of Chad. In November 2026, at a campaign rally in Jos, Tinubu himself apologised for the limited nature of that visit, saying: "When I last visited, the other time, I was limited to the airport; forgive me if you didn't see me in the hinterland, but I saw the devastation." Critics say a President who can travel to Jos for votes in November 2026 could have travelled to Yelewata and Angwan Rukuba for victims in June 2025 and April 2026. Supporters say the President visited the states, met survivors, and directed security agencies to act, and that security considerations, weather and scheduling limit any President's movements.

On electricity, Tinubu set his own test. In December 2022, campaigning before members of the Organised Private Sector in Lagos, he said, on a recording later played on Channels Television: "You must have electricity. And you will not pay for estimated bills anymore. A promise made, will be a promise kept. If I couldn't keep the promise and you and I come back for second term, don't vote for me." Former Minister Babatunde Fashola, who said he was present, argued on Channels in November 2026 that the recording was cut short, and that Tinubu had added a qualification: "Unless I give you adequate reasons." Fashola also disputed that Tinubu had promised 24-hour supply, saying he had promised adequate supply. The administration cites the Electricity Act 2023, the Presidential Metering Initiative, and a N4 trillion programme to settle power-sector debts, including N3.3 trillion approved in April 2026 for verified legacy debts, as evidence of work done. Critics say the test has not been met on the President's own terms. According to the Nigerian Electricity Regulatory Commission, Nigeria's 28 grid-connected plants had an average available capacity of just 4,286 megawatts in April 2026, out of an installed capacity of 13,625 megawatts. The grid collapsed repeatedly — 12 times in 2025, and twice in January 2026 alone, according to press reports citing system operator data. Tariffs rose by about 240 percent since 2023 for Band A customers, while many Nigerians say they still pay estimated bills and still receive only a few hours of supply a day. The World Bank, critics note, cancelled N717.7 billion in electricity loans after reform benchmarks were missed. Supporters say generation has improved in some areas, that a record 5,801.84 megawatts was reached in March 2025, and that the sector cannot be fixed in one term. Critics reply that Tinubu himself said not to vote for him if he failed, unless he gave adequate reasons — and that explanations are not electricity.

This feature does not diagnose Tinubu. Only a medical panel can, under Section 144. What it does is set out the procedure. Two-thirds of the Federal Executive Council declares him incapable. A panel of five doctors, appointed by the Senate President, verifies after examination. If the panel certifies infirmity of body or mind rendering him permanently incapable, a notice signed by the Senate President and Speaker is published in the Gazette. He ceases to hold office. The Vice-President holds it. That procedure was written for Yar'Adua. It was written for Buhari. The Ministers have not invoked it. The Senate President has not appointed a panel. That is not proof of incapacity. It is proof that the constitutional question has not been tested.

Johnson asks us to be wary when patriotism is used as a shield against scrutiny. The Constitution asks us to do something different: to test capacity through process, not through insult. If a President cannot discharge the functions of his office, the Constitution provides a way to establish that, fairly, medically, and publicly. Until that process is used, the public will be left with videos, transcripts, and questions. A leader who cannot discharge the functions of his office cannot hold the office. Whether that is the case here is for a medical panel, not for a newspaper, to decide.

Post a Comment

0 Comments